— Published January 18, 2021

To survive, Olympism must complete its democratic transformation

Tribune Focus

Is Olympism today at a crossroads? Patrick Clastres, professor at the University of Lausanne, believes so. But for the historian, the challenge of the Olympic movement is not directly linked to the organization of the Tokyo Games. It is based on its ability to be compatible with human rights. He explained it in a column for Le Temps. We publish it with the kind permission of the Swiss daily.

 

After the sporting world was shut down in 2020 due to the global pandemic, 2021 presents itself as a high-risk year for the International Olympic Committee (IOC). Since the declaration of a new state of emergency in Tokyo on January 7, 2021, the question has once again been raised about the holding of the Olympic Games in Japan despite their postponement for a year. We can bet that stakeholders will be able to take advantage of progress in vaccination to make this world event a success. The Land of the Rising Sun and the IOC, like their economic and media partners, will thus be able to save face, set a fine example of resilience through sport, ensure financial income and offer athletes and spectators the opportunity to a re-enchantment.

Making Olympism compatible with democracy

But, from our point of view, the real issue lies elsewhere. And it is of much greater significance for international sport and, in a certain way, for the fate of humanity: to make Olympism once and for all compatible with democracy, in particular with the defense of human rights. human rights and freedoms as defined in 1948 by the UN. Because the Olympic Games, despite the political uses that the governments that host them can make of them, offer themselves as the only spectacular and fun moment, certainly fictional, where the people of the world meet, have fun and recognize each other.

They have the advantage of being competitions that are both international, in the sense that the athletes wear national jerseys, and transnational since these same athletes can be transformed into global icons by assuming their origins and their identities. Nothing like this at the UN, which functions as a forum where state diplomacies clash more than they cooperate. However, there are numerous threats hovering over the said Olympic movement.

Meeting spaces

Invariably, since the 1920s, many international sports federations have tried to go it alone, like FIFA, which launched its football World Cup in 1930. We must also take into account the professional leagues, which dominate the United States, and whose model tends to spread in Europe and Asia to the detriment of the pyramid principle of the federations. Let us also not forget the multinational companies, like Red Bull, and the major media which are capable of inventing a sporting event from scratch and imposing it on the world calendar. Finally, the IOC must learn to reckon with the athletes themselves as soon as they organize themselves into professional unions on a global scale, like golf players since the 1930s or tennis players since 1968.

Certainly, we could very well imagine a sporting planet without the Olympic Games, nor international sports federations, nor even the IOC. All in all, there is no regulatory entity at the international level in terms of cultural creation. Can we imagine international jazz or theater federations which would affiliate musicians and actors within the framework of clubs and for the purposes of rivalry? So what is the point of keeping all these sports organizations if not for democratic and emancipatory purposes? Not so much to impose ways of thinking, ways of being with one's body, or moralizing formulas, but to offer meeting spaces based on volunteerism, on the one member/one voice principle and open to otherness.

Take responsibility for your past

In other words, faced with the new threats posed by dictatorships and anti-democratic impulses on the progress of the world, it is urgent that the IOC accomplish its historical, ideological and institutional aggiornamento both to ensure its survival and to set a new sporting and democratic course. to humanity. After having accomplished its economic transformation under the presidencies of Killanin and Samaranch, and while it is engaged in a reform of its sports program which will ultimately cause it to abandon many sporting disciplines of the world before, the IOC must enter into level in the democratic era. For this, several reforms seem necessary to us.

First, he must put an end to his mania for official history which makes him ignore, among other things, the Nazi orchestration of the Berlin 1936 Games or the boycotts of the Moscow 1980 and Los Angeles 1984 Games, and which prevents it from honoring the African-American athletes who brandished their fists on the podium in Mexico 1968. Taking responsibility for one's history means being able to look to the future. The IOC must also improve the way it protects itself from political or commercial intrusions within it. Before carrying out deeper democratic reforms, it could use the principle of co-optation of its members to recruit major sports leaders who are recognized defenders of human rights.

Two birds with one stone

Such a democratic renewal would also give it the opportunity to resolve the question of the freedom of speech of athletes in the Olympic space which is currently refused to them under its rule 50. To prevent the stadium from transforming into a political shambles, which no one wants a priori, the IOC should include in its Charter the explicit reference to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Two birds with one stone. By making a distinction between political opinions which fall within the private forum and human rights which belong to all of humanity, it would thus block the relativism of dictatorships which denounce the UN Declaration of December 10, 1948 as a tool of domination forged by the West.

The IOC President could then pose as a defender of individual rights and freedoms and thus protect IOC members and athletes who would be threatened in their own countries. By becoming compatible with human rights, Olympism could put an end to its demons and become, why not, a democratic and emancipatory myth.